| Coulomb's law: like charges repel, unlike attract | |
|---|---|
| The field: force per unit charge, added as vectors | |
| Potential and energy: added as plain numbers |
Lesson
The theory β Electric Field Visualiser
The electric field at a point is the force a small positive test charge would feel there, divided by that charge: E = F/qβ. A point charge q makes a field of size k|q|/rΒ², pointing away from it when q is positive and towards it when q is negative, and the fields of several charges add as vectors.
What each symbol means
k- Coulomb's constant, 1/(4ΟΞ΅β) = 8.988 Γ 10βΉ NΒ·mΒ²/CΒ²
r_i- the distance from charge i to the point P
Γͺ_i- the direction of charge i's field at P, a vector of length 1: from the charge towards P when qi is positive, from P towards the charge when it is negative
Where the formula comes from
- Coulomb's law. Two point charges push or pull along the line joining them, with a force that falls as the square of the distance.
- Divide out the test charge. What is left belongs to the source alone. That is the field, and it is there at P whether or not anything sits at P to feel it.
- Add the fields by components. Each charge contributes its size Ei times its direction Γͺi; the green arrow at P is the sum.
- Add the potentials as plain numbers. V keeps the sign of each charge and has no direction, so nothing cancels by geometry. The field points the way V falls fastest, across the dashed equipotentials.
- Energy. Moving a charge q from A to B takes work q(VB β VA) along any path. Assembling the whole arrangement from far apart takes one term for every pair.
- Assumes
- Charges at rest and small enough to be points. The picture is a flat slice through the charges, but the charges are ordinary three-dimensional point charges: their fields fall as 1/rΒ² and their potentials as 1/r.
Problems solved in full
-
The field of one charge, and the force it exerts 3 steps
A charge of +4.0 ΞΌC sits at the origin. Find the electric field at P = (2.0 m, 0), and the force on a β2.0 ΞΌC charge placed at P.
-
The size comes from Coulomb's law with the test charge divided out:
-
A positive charge's field points away from it, along the line from the charge to P:
-
The force on a charge at P is that charge times the field. A negative charge is pushed against the field:
Answer
E = 8,988 N/C along +x; F = 1.798 Γ 10β»Β² N along βx. The field at P is the 4.0 ΞΌC charge's alone: put a different charge at P and the force changes, the field does not.
-
-
Two charges on a line 4 steps
A charge of +2.0 ΞΌC sits at x = 0 and a charge of β3.0 ΞΌC at x = 4.0 m. Find the field at x = 1.0 m and at x = β2.0 m.
Show solution
-
The size of each charge's field at x = 1.0 m, where the distances are 1.0 m and 3.0 m:
-
Between the charges both fields point the same way, away from the positive charge and towards the negative one, so both along +x. They add:
-
At x = β2.0 m, to the left of both, the positive charge's field points away from it (βx) and the negative charge's towards it (+x):
-
Opposite directions subtract, and the larger wins:
Answer
2.097 Γ 10β΄ N/C along +x at x = 1.0 m; 3,745 N/C along βx at x = β2.0 m. Between two unlike charges the fields always add. Only outside them do they oppose, so that is the only place the field can vanish (problem 4).
-
-
A point off the line: add by components 4 steps
A charge of +3.0 ΞΌC sits at the origin and a charge of β2.0 ΞΌC at (0, 3.0 m). Find the size and direction of the field at P = (4.0 m, 0).
Show solution
-
The positive charge is 4.0 m away along the x axis, and its field at P points away from it, along +x:
-
The negative charge is 5.0 m away, the long side of a 3β4β5 triangle. Its field points from P back towards it: the unit vector from the charge to P is (4, β3)/5, so the field's direction is minus that:
-
Add the components, never the sizes:
-
Then rebuild the size and the angle. Ex is positive, so the inverse tangent gives the angle directly:
Answer
1,191 N/C at 21.24Β° above the +x axis. Adding the two sizes would give 2,404 N/C, twice the right answer, because the two fields point 143Β° apart.
-
-
Where the field is zero 4 steps
A charge of +4.0 ΞΌC sits at x = 0 and a charge of β1.0 ΞΌC at x = 3.0 m. Where on the x axis, other than far away, is the field zero?
Show solution
-
Two fields cancel only where they point opposite ways. Between unlike charges they point the same way (problem 2), so the point lies outside, on the side of the smaller charge, where being nearer can make up for being smaller. There the sizes must be equal:
-
Cancel k and take the square root of both sides:
-
Each sign gives a candidate. At x = 2.0 m, between the charges, the sizes match but both fields point along +x, so they add; that root is rejected:
-
At x = 6.0 m the two fields are equal in size and opposite in direction:
Answer
x = 6.0 m, 3.0 m beyond the β1.0 ΞΌC charge. Setting the sizes equal also finds the point where the sizes match and the directions do not, and only the directions can throw that root out.
-
-
The force on one charge of three 3 steps
Charges of +2.0 ΞΌC sit at (β3.0 m, 0) and (3.0 m, 0), and a third charge of +1.0 ΞΌC at (0, 4.0 m). Find the net force on the third charge.
Show solution
-
Find the field the other two charges make where the third one sits. Both are 5.0 m away:
-
By symmetry the x components cancel and the y components add:
-
The force on the third charge is its charge times that field, along +y, away from the pair:
Answer
1.15 Γ 10β»Β³ N along +y. The third charge is left out of the field at its own position: a charge's field acts on every other charge and never on itself.
-
-
Potential, and the work to move a charge 3 steps
The two +2.0 ΞΌC charges of problem 5 stay where they are, and the +1.0 ΞΌC charge is moved from A = (0, 4.0 m) to the origin B. How much work does the mover do?
Show solution
-
Potential is a plain sum with no directions. At A both charges are 5.0 m away:
-
At B both are 3.0 m away:
-
The work done against the field is the charge times the rise in potential, whatever path it takes:
Answer
4.793 Γ 10β»Β³ J. The field at B is zero, because the two pushes cancel there, and the work to get there is not: work follows the potential, which rises all the way from A to B, not the field at the end point.
-
-
The energy of an arrangement 3 steps
Charges of +3.0 ΞΌC at the origin, β2.0 ΞΌC at (0, 3.0 m) and +1.0 ΞΌC at (4.0 m, 0) are brought together from far apart. How much work did that take?
Show solution
-
Bring them in one at a time. The first costs nothing; each later one costs its charge times the potential the earlier ones make where it lands. Added up, every pair appears once:
-
The three distances:
-
Each pair keeps its signs:
Answer
β1.483 Γ 10β»Β² J. Negative: the two attracting pairs outweigh the one repelling pair, so the field did the work, and pulling the three apart again would cost 1.483 Γ 10β»Β² J.
-
-
The dipole arrangement with two charges 4 units apart 6 steps
Two charges of equal size and opposite sign sit 4 units apart. Find the field and the potential at the midpoint between them, then find how the field behaves far away. This is the Dipole arrangement: q1 = +1 at (-2, 0), q2 = -1 at (+2, 0), with the probe at the origin.
Show solution
-
Superposition is the whole of electrostatics: each charge builds its field as though the other were not there, and you add the vectors. The vector that matters points from the charge to the probe, which is what lets the sign of q decide whether the field runs away from the charge or back into it.
-
The positive charge sits 2 units to the left, so its vector to the probe points 2 units right, and the cube of 2 in the denominator gives 0.250. Positive charge, outward field: this contribution points right.
-
The negative charge sits 2 units to the right, so its vector points left β and q is negative, which flips it again. Two flips, and the contribution points right as well. Pause here: the charges are on opposite sides of the probe and carry opposite signs, and those two oppositions cancel instead of compounding.
-
So the two contributions add head to tail rather than fighting, and the pair delivers 0.500 where either charge alone would deliver 0.250.
-
The potential does the opposite thing with the same two charges. V is a scalar, so it carries the sign of q and nothing else, and the two distances are equal β the terms are +0.500 and -0.500 and the midpoint sits at V = 0. Field and potential are not two readings of one quantity: here one doubles and the other vanishes at the same point.
-
Now leave the midpoint. Put the probe at height y on the perpendicular bisector, where both charges are the same distance away. The vertical components cancel by symmetry and the horizontal ones survive, giving one formula for the whole line. Set y = 0 in it and it has to reproduce the number you already have β it does, which is how you know the formula is the same physics and not a new one.
Answer
The tool prints |E| = 0.5 at the origin, assembled from two contributions of 0.25 that point the same way, and V = 0 at that same point. Step 6 is the one to keep. Far out, the two 1/rΒ² fields very nearly cancel, and what survives is set by the separation and falls as 1/yΒ³ β one whole power of distance faster than a single charge. The ratio is 2a/y = 4/y, so at y = 20 this pair musters just under a fifth of what one lone charge of the same size would produce there. The reason is printed one row above the field: Qtotal = 0. The 1/rΒ² term belongs to the total charge, and when that is zero the separation is the only thing left to feel. A neutral pair is not invisible β it is short-ranged, and those are different things.
-
-
Two identical positive charges 3 units apart 5 steps
Two identical positive charges, 3 units apart. Find the field and the potential at the midpoint, then decide whether a positive test charge released there would stay. This is the Two + arrangement: q1 = +1 at (-1.5, 0), q2 = +1 at (+1.5, 0), probe at the origin.
Show solution
-
Same probe, same superposition, opposite outcome. Both charges are 1.500 from the origin and both are positive, so the two contributions are the same size and point in exactly opposite directions. They annihilate, and the field at the midpoint is 0.
-
The potential cannot cancel, because a scalar has no direction to cancel in. Both terms are +0.667 and V is 1.333. A point where E = 0 but V β 0 is not a paradox: E is the slope of V, and a slope of zero tells you nothing about the height.
-
Zero slope is a hilltop, a valley or a mountain pass, and only one of the three holds a ball. Nudge the test charge a distance x along the line joining the charges. The nearer charge now pushes harder than the far one, the difference points back at the origin, and the restoring stiffness is 4q/aΒ³ = 1.1852.
-
Nudge it perpendicular instead. Now both charges are behind it, both push the same way, and it keeps going. Same two charges, same probe, opposite verdict β and the expelling stiffness is 2q/aΒ³ = 0.5926, exactly half the restoring one.
-
Out of the plane is the perpendicular case again, because two points have nothing to distinguish one direction around their axis from another. So there are three stiffnesses, one negative and two positive, and they sum to zero. Not nearly zero.
Answer
The tool prints |E| = 0 from two contributions of 0.444 that cancel, and V = 1.333 from two of 0.667 that do not. The null is a pass, not a valley: stable along the line joining the charges, unstable across it. That was never a choice about where to put the charges. The three stiffnesses are minus the three second derivatives of V, and their sum is the divergence of E, which is zero wherever no charge sits, so every direction that pulls a test charge back has to be paid for by directions that push it away. No fixed arrangement of charges can hold another charge in stable equilibrium, however cleverly it is arranged. That is Earnshaw's theorem, and you have just obtained it from three numbers whose starting point the tool printed. A trap that holds a charged particle at rest therefore needs more than a static electric field: a Penning trap adds a magnetic field, a Paul trap makes the electric field oscillate.
-
Supplementary problems, answers only
-
Find the size and direction of the field 30 cm from a charge of β4.0 nC.
Show answer
399.4 N/C, pointing towards the charge.
-
Charges of +4.0 ΞΌC at x = 0 and +1.0 ΞΌC at x = 3.0 m. Where between them is the field zero?
Show answer
x = 2.0 m.
-
Charges of +1.0 ΞΌC sit at (β1.0 m, 0) and (1.0 m, 0). Find the field at (0, 1.0 m).
Show answer
6,355 N/C along +y.
-
A square of side 2.0 m has +1.0 ΞΌC at three corners and β1.0 ΞΌC at the fourth. Find the field and the potential at its centre.
Show answer
8,988 N/C, pointing at the negative corner; 1.271 Γ 10β΄ V.
-
A 2.0 g bead carrying +3.0 ΞΌC is released from rest 0.20 m from a fixed +5.0 ΞΌC charge. How fast is it moving when it is far away?
Show answer
25.96 m/s: all of the 0.6741 J of energy becomes kinetic energy.
-
Four charges of +1.0 ΞΌC sit at the corners of a square of side 1.0 m. How much work did it take to put them there?
Show answer
4.866 Γ 10β»Β² J: four sides and two diagonals, (4 + β2)kqΒ²/a.
Learning path
Where fields come from
References (1)
- Insight block 3 β why the null point between two like charges is a saddle and not a trap: S. Earnshaw, "On the nature of the molecular forces which regulate the constitution of the luminiferous ether." Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 7, 97β112, 1842.